• 你的代码是直接复制粘贴上来的吗?第一个代码的 xpath 有错,@text=‘中文'第一个引号是中文引号。

  • Appium 中 iOS 下的 Hybrid at 2015年02月23日

    学习了!这样的原理剖析不仅学会了原理,还知道了应该如何正确使用这个功能。

  • 能附上 Appium 端的错误信息吗?

  • @cosyman 所以我注明了 需要能连接国外网络。确实 chromedriver 没代理下不下来。你有调整过 reset.sh 来让它下载 chromedriver 的节点改为国内镜像吗?有的话麻烦在这里说一下,我更新到帖子内容里。谢谢。

  • @lihuazhang 现在还没做到这一步。我后面跑一下测试后再加上。看官方文档的话 unittest 只需要一个命令就可以跑了,不过里面有没有坑现在还不清楚……

  • @lihuazhang 好的,明白了。第一组双星号前面必须有一个空格。谢谢指导。

  • @lihuazhang 我这边确实有问题。用输入法输的:粗体。复制页面底部示例的:粗体。我用的浏览器:Safari version 8.0.2 (10600.2.5)
    可以确定我没用全角或者加了空格。全角的写法是××粗体××,在这个字体下还是很明显的。
    markdown 是浏览器 js 处理还是发到服务器才处理的?如果是浏览器 js 处理可能是我网速问题导致 Js 加载不完整,或者是 js 的浏览器兼容性问题,所以粗体没有被正确转换把。
    后面我再深入看看。

  • 现在可以了。粗体。昨天确实不行,修复了就好。谢谢!

  • @monkey 论坛的 markdown 粗体是不是有问题?怎么粗体不会转成粗体的?

  • 能把解决方法同时附到主内容里面吗?这样方便后面的人快速参考。

  • data:text/html,chromewebdata应该是 chromedriver 启动浏览器的默认 url。至于加载不成功为啥会返回这个我只找到 selenium 有个相关 issue。官方标记为 fixed 但后面有人说在部分浏览器中还存在。
    传送门(请科学上网):
    Issue 4301: getCurrentUrl should return the current URL on a 404 page
    建议换个方式来验证页面是否加载成功吧。

    PS: 话说神马是 H5 自动化 ?该不会是 html5 自动化 吧?

  • @doctorq 谢谢支持!后面我会放到我自己的 blog 里面的,也会发个总结帖说明一下,还会发些分享帖说明如何进行 remote debug 来查看 app 使用 android api 时内部具体是怎么做的。现在在这里记录的只是原始资料,所以也只是跟帖而已。

  • 今天看了findAccessibilityNodeInfoByAccessibilityIdUiThread,虽然还没完全了解它的流程,但基本找到--compress影响的位置了。
    这里
    先回到上次的地方:

    private void findAccessibilityNodeInfoByAccessibilityIdUiThread(Message message) {
            final int flags = message.arg1;
    
            SomeArgs args = (SomeArgs) message.obj;
            final int accessibilityViewId = args.argi1;
            final int virtualDescendantId = args.argi2;
            final int interactionId = args.argi3;
            final IAccessibilityInteractionConnectionCallback callback =
                (IAccessibilityInteractionConnectionCallback) args.arg1;
            final MagnificationSpec spec = (MagnificationSpec) args.arg2;
    
            args.recycle();
    
            List<AccessibilityNodeInfo> infos = mTempAccessibilityNodeInfoList;
            infos.clear();
            try {
                if (mViewRootImpl.mView == null || mViewRootImpl.mAttachInfo == null) {
                    return;
                }
                mViewRootImpl.mAttachInfo.mAccessibilityFetchFlags = flags;
                View root = null;
                if (accessibilityViewId == AccessibilityNodeInfo.UNDEFINED) {
                    root = mViewRootImpl.mView;
                } else {
                    root = findViewByAccessibilityId(accessibilityViewId);
                }
                if (root != null && isShown(root)) {
                    mPrefetcher.prefetchAccessibilityNodeInfos(root, virtualDescendantId, flags, infos);
                }
            } finally {
                try {
                    mViewRootImpl.mAttachInfo.mAccessibilityFetchFlags = 0;
                    applyAppScaleAndMagnificationSpecIfNeeded(infos, spec);
                    if (spec != null) {
                        spec.recycle();
                    }
                    callback.setFindAccessibilityNodeInfosResult(infos, interactionId);
                    infos.clear();
                } catch (RemoteException re) {
                    /* ignore - the other side will time out */
                }
            }
        }
    

    这里对flags进行了几个操作:

    1. 取出 message 里面存储的各个变量。其中有我们最关注的flags
    2. flags赋值给mViewRootImpl.mAttachInfo.mAccessibilityFetchFlags
    3. 在查出 root 且root != null && isShown(root)(这里暂时先不探究root是什么),执行mPrefetcher.prefetchAccessibilityNodeInfos方法。isShown(root)是判断当前节点是否会显示在界面上,相关源码:
      android.view.AccessibilityInteractionController

      private boolean isShown(View view) {
          // The first two checks are made also made by isShown() which
          // however traverses the tree up to the parent to catch that.
          // Therefore, we do some fail fast check to minimize the up
          // tree traversal.
          return (view.mAttachInfo != null
                  && view.mAttachInfo.mWindowVisibility == View.VISIBLE
                  && view.isShown());
      }
      

      里面的view.isShown()源码:
      android.view.View

      /**
       * Returns the visibility of this view and all of its ancestors
       *
       * @return True if this view and all of its ancestors are {@link #VISIBLE}
       */
      public boolean isShown() {
          View current = this;
          //noinspection ConstantConditions
          do {
              if ((current.mViewFlags & VISIBILITY_MASK) != VISIBLE) {
                  return false;
              }
              ViewParent parent = current.mParent;
              if (parent == null) {
                  return false; // We are not attached to the view root
              }
              if (!(parent instanceof View)) {
                  return true;
              }
              current = (View) parent;
          } while (current != null);
      
          return false;
      }
      

    回到正题,我们来看看mPrefetcher.prefetchAccessibilityNodeInfos方法:

    /**
         * This class encapsulates a prefetching strategy for the accessibility APIs for
         * querying window content. It is responsible to prefetch a batch of
         * AccessibilityNodeInfos in addition to the one for a requested node.
         */
        private class AccessibilityNodePrefetcher {
    
            private static final int MAX_ACCESSIBILITY_NODE_INFO_BATCH_SIZE = 50;
    
            private final ArrayList<View> mTempViewList = new ArrayList<View>();
    
            public void prefetchAccessibilityNodeInfos(View view, int virtualViewId, int fetchFlags,
                    List<AccessibilityNodeInfo> outInfos) {
                AccessibilityNodeProvider provider = view.getAccessibilityNodeProvider();
                if (provider == null) {
                    AccessibilityNodeInfo root = view.createAccessibilityNodeInfo();
                    if (root != null) {
                        outInfos.add(root);
                        if ((fetchFlags & AccessibilityNodeInfo.FLAG_PREFETCH_PREDECESSORS) != 0) {
                            prefetchPredecessorsOfRealNode(view, outInfos);
                        }
                        if ((fetchFlags & AccessibilityNodeInfo.FLAG_PREFETCH_SIBLINGS) != 0) {
                            prefetchSiblingsOfRealNode(view, outInfos);
                        }
                        if ((fetchFlags & AccessibilityNodeInfo.FLAG_PREFETCH_DESCENDANTS) != 0) {
                            prefetchDescendantsOfRealNode(view, outInfos);
                        }
                    }
                } else {
                    AccessibilityNodeInfo root = provider.createAccessibilityNodeInfo(virtualViewId);
                    if (root != null) {
                        outInfos.add(root);
                        if ((fetchFlags & AccessibilityNodeInfo.FLAG_PREFETCH_PREDECESSORS) != 0) {
                            prefetchPredecessorsOfVirtualNode(root, view, provider, outInfos);
                        }
                        if ((fetchFlags & AccessibilityNodeInfo.FLAG_PREFETCH_SIBLINGS) != 0) {
                            prefetchSiblingsOfVirtualNode(root, view, provider, outInfos);
                        }
                        if ((fetchFlags & AccessibilityNodeInfo.FLAG_PREFETCH_DESCENDANTS) != 0) {
                            prefetchDescendantsOfVirtualNode(root, provider, outInfos);
                        }
                    }
                }
            }
    

    其中fetchFlags就是之前的flags,根据前面return findAccessibilityNodeInfoByAccessibilityId(connectionId,AccessibilityNodeInfo.ACTIVE_WINDOW_ID, AccessibilityNodeInfo.ROOT_NODE_ID,false, AccessibilityNodeInfo.FLAG_PREFETCH_DESCENDANTS);,此处进入的是(fetchFlags & AccessibilityNodeInfo.FLAG_PREFETCH_DESCENDANTS) != 0为 true 后进入的方法。
    至于是进入prefetchDescendantsOfRealNode还是prefetchDescendantsOfVirtualNode,目前还不能确定(不是调试环境,确定不了 root 的值)。咱们逐个看:

    prefetchDescendantsOfRealNode:

    private void prefetchDescendantsOfRealNode(View root,
                    List<AccessibilityNodeInfo> outInfos) {
                if (!(root instanceof ViewGroup)) {
                    return;
                }
                HashMap<View, AccessibilityNodeInfo> addedChildren =
                    new HashMap<View, AccessibilityNodeInfo>();
                ArrayList<View> children = mTempViewList;
                children.clear();
                try {
                    root.addChildrenForAccessibility(children);
                    final int childCount = children.size();
                    for (int i = 0; i < childCount; i++) {
                        if (outInfos.size() >= MAX_ACCESSIBILITY_NODE_INFO_BATCH_SIZE) {
                            return;
                        }
                        View child = children.get(i);
                        if (isShown(child)) {
                            AccessibilityNodeProvider provider = child.getAccessibilityNodeProvider();
                            if (provider == null) {
                                AccessibilityNodeInfo info = child.createAccessibilityNodeInfo();
                                if (info != null) {
                                    outInfos.add(info);
                                    addedChildren.put(child, null);
                                }
                            } else {
                                AccessibilityNodeInfo info = provider.createAccessibilityNodeInfo(
                                       AccessibilityNodeInfo.UNDEFINED);
                                if (info != null) {
                                    outInfos.add(info);
                                    addedChildren.put(child, info);
                                }
                            }
                        }
                    }
                } finally {
                    children.clear();
                }
                if (outInfos.size() < MAX_ACCESSIBILITY_NODE_INFO_BATCH_SIZE) {
                    for (Map.Entry<View, AccessibilityNodeInfo> entry : addedChildren.entrySet()) {
                        View addedChild = entry.getKey();
                        AccessibilityNodeInfo virtualRoot = entry.getValue();
                        if (virtualRoot == null) {
                            prefetchDescendantsOfRealNode(addedChild, outInfos);
                        } else {
                            AccessibilityNodeProvider provider =
                                addedChild.getAccessibilityNodeProvider();
                            prefetchDescendantsOfVirtualNode(virtualRoot, provider, outInfos);
                        }
                    }
                }
            }
    
    1. 判断root是不是ViewGroup的实例(这里应该是,否则返回值就是空了)
    2. 建立两个变量addedChildren, children(此时 children 使用过 clear() 方法,所以已经是空列表了)
    3. 通过root.addChildrenForAccessibility(children)获取root的子节点并添加到children列表中。
    4. 后面的语句主要就是遍历children的元素,然后把所有会显示的元素都加到outInfosoutInfos就是最终会返回到 callback 中的节点列表。
    5. 如果找到的节点数outInfos小于MAX_ACCESSIBILITY_NODE_INFO_BATCH_SIZE,那就在前面找到的 child 节点中继续找(递归),直到root不是ViewGroup实例或者outInfos大小达标。

    所以关键语句就是root.addChildrenForAccessibility(children)。咱们进去看看:
    android.view.View

    /**
     * Adds the children of a given View for accessibility. Since some Views are
     * not important for accessibility the children for accessibility are not
     * necessarily direct children of the view, rather they are the first level of
     * descendants important for accessibility.
     *
     * @param children The list of children for accessibility.
     */
    public void addChildrenForAccessibility(ArrayList<View> children) {
        if (includeForAccessibility()) {
            children.add(this);
        }
    }
    

    然后进去includeForAccessibility():

    /**
     * Whether to regard this view for accessibility. A view is regarded for
     * accessibility if it is important for accessibility or the querying
     * accessibility service has explicitly requested that view not
     * important for accessibility are regarded.
     *
     * @return Whether to regard the view for accessibility.
     *
     * @hide
     */
    public boolean includeForAccessibility() {
        //noinspection SimplifiableIfStatement
        if (mAttachInfo != null) {
            return (mAttachInfo.mAccessibilityFetchFlags
                    & AccessibilityNodeInfo.FLAG_INCLUDE_NOT_IMPORTANT_VIEWS) != 0
                    || isImportantForAccessibility();
        }
        return false;
    }
    

    比较接近了,这个地方就是判断这个 view 对 accessibility 而言是否重要的地方。如果不重要且AccessibilityNodeInfo.FLAG_INCLUDE_NOT_IMPORTANT_VIEWS标志位为 0(我们的 compress 就是做了这件事),那就返回 false。
    既然第一个条件mAttachInfo.mAccessibilityFetchFlags & AccessibilityNodeInfo.FLAG_INCLUDE_NOT_IMPORTANT_VIEWS) != 0的结果我们已经知道是 false 了,那就去看isImportantForAccessibility()

    /**
     * Gets whether this view should be exposed for accessibility.
     *
     * @return Whether the view is exposed for accessibility.
     *
     * @hide
     */
    public boolean isImportantForAccessibility() {
        final int mode = (mPrivateFlags2 & PFLAG2_IMPORTANT_FOR_ACCESSIBILITY_MASK)
                >> PFLAG2_IMPORTANT_FOR_ACCESSIBILITY_SHIFT;
        if (mode == IMPORTANT_FOR_ACCESSIBILITY_NO
                || mode == IMPORTANT_FOR_ACCESSIBILITY_NO_HIDE_DESCENDANTS) {
            return false;
        }
    
        // Check parent mode to ensure we're not hidden.
        ViewParent parent = mParent;
        while (parent instanceof View) {
            if (((View) parent).getImportantForAccessibility()
                    == IMPORTANT_FOR_ACCESSIBILITY_NO_HIDE_DESCENDANTS) {
                return false;
            }
            parent = parent.getParent();
        }
    
        return mode == IMPORTANT_FOR_ACCESSIBILITY_YES || isActionableForAccessibility()
                || hasListenersForAccessibility() || getAccessibilityNodeProvider() != null
                || getAccessibilityLiveRegion() != ACCESSIBILITY_LIVE_REGION_NONE;
    }
    

    这就是prefetchDescendantsOfRealNode最终的判断位置了。主要有 3 部分:

    1. 判断 mode 的值 final int mode = (mPrivateFlags2 & PFLAG2_IMPORTANT_FOR_ACCESSIBILITY_MASK) >> PFLAG2_IMPORTANT_FOR_ACCESSIBILITY_SHIFT; if (mode == IMPORTANT_FOR_ACCESSIBILITY_NO || mode == IMPORTANT_FOR_ACCESSIBILITY_NO_HIDE_DESCENDANTS) { return false; } 其中IMPORTANT_FOR_ACCESSIBILITY_NO_HIDE_DESCENDANTS的解释: /** * The view is not important for accessibility, nor are any of its * descendant views. */ public static final int IMPORTANT_FOR_ACCESSIBILITY_NO_HIDE_DESCENDANTS = 0x00000004;
    2. 判断父节点及祖先节点是否为 IMPORTANT_FOR_ACCESSIBILITY_NO_HIDE_DESCENDANTS(对 ACCESSIBILITY 不重要且对它的后代而言也不重要) // Check parent mode to ensure we're not hidden. ViewParent parent = mParent; while (parent instanceof View) { if (((View) parent).getImportantForAccessibility() == IMPORTANT_FOR_ACCESSIBILITY_NO_HIDE_DESCENDANTS) { return false; } parent = parent.getParent(); }
    3. 判断 mode 是否为IMPORTANT_FOR_ACCESSIBILITY_YES及是否具有其它和 Accessibility 相关的特性: return mode == IMPORTANT_FOR_ACCESSIBILITY_YES || isActionableForAccessibility() || hasListenersForAccessibility() || getAccessibilityNodeProvider() != null || getAccessibilityLiveRegion() != ACCESSIBILITY_LIVE_REGION_NONE; 先记着。咱们去看另一个路线prefetchDescendantsOfVirtualNode

    prefetchDescendantsOfVirtualNode:

    private void prefetchDescendantsOfVirtualNode(AccessibilityNodeInfo root,
            AccessibilityNodeProvider provider, List<AccessibilityNodeInfo> outInfos) {
        SparseLongArray childNodeIds = root.getChildNodeIds();
        final int initialOutInfosSize = outInfos.size();
        final int childCount = childNodeIds.size();
        for (int i = 0; i < childCount; i++) {
            if (outInfos.size() >= MAX_ACCESSIBILITY_NODE_INFO_BATCH_SIZE) {
                return;
            }
            final long childNodeId = childNodeIds.get(i);
            AccessibilityNodeInfo child = provider.createAccessibilityNodeInfo(
                    AccessibilityNodeInfo.getVirtualDescendantId(childNodeId));
            if (child != null) {
                outInfos.add(child);
            }
        }
        if (outInfos.size() < MAX_ACCESSIBILITY_NODE_INFO_BATCH_SIZE) {
            final int addedChildCount = outInfos.size() - initialOutInfosSize;
            for (int i = 0; i < addedChildCount; i++) {
                AccessibilityNodeInfo child = outInfos.get(initialOutInfosSize + i);
                prefetchDescendantsOfVirtualNode(child, provider, outInfos);
            }
        }
    }
    

    流程差不多,先找 children 节点,然后遍历,最后如果 size 不够,继续在 child 节点中找,直到节点数达标。咱们来看`:
    android.view.accessibility.AccessibilityNodeInfo`

    /**
     * @return The ids of the children.
     *
     * @hide
     */
    public SparseLongArray getChildNodeIds() {
        return mChildNodeIds;
    }
    

    很直接,直接返回一个列表。
    注意这里并没有校验这个 node 对 Accessibility 重要。估计是因为 VirtualNode 通常出现在自定义的 view,这些 view 的元素不一定都有 flag 或者可以判断是否重要的属性。

    这里说明一下,每个 view 里面的 node 既可以作为在整个页面中都可以找到的真正的 node(ReadNode),也可以使用仅在 view 内有效、仅能通过 view 的 provider 来查找的的 node(VirtualNode,详情可看AccessibilityNodeProvider)。因此会存在两个遍历 node 的方法。

    至于为什么前面容器类控件(FrameLayout 等)会被 compress 干掉,目前还没找到确切的原因,不过已经可以肯定是在下面三个地方其中一个确定的:

    1. 判断 mode 的值 final int mode = (mPrivateFlags2 & PFLAG2_IMPORTANT_FOR_ACCESSIBILITY_MASK) >> PFLAG2_IMPORTANT_FOR_ACCESSIBILITY_SHIFT; if (mode == IMPORTANT_FOR_ACCESSIBILITY_NO || mode == IMPORTANT_FOR_ACCESSIBILITY_NO_HIDE_DESCENDANTS) { return false; } 其中IMPORTANT_FOR_ACCESSIBILITY_NO_HIDE_DESCENDANTS的解释: /** * The view is not important for accessibility, nor are any of its * descendant views. */ public static final int IMPORTANT_FOR_ACCESSIBILITY_NO_HIDE_DESCENDANTS = 0x00000004;
    2. 判断父节点及祖先节点是否为 IMPORTANT_FOR_ACCESSIBILITY_NO_HIDE_DESCENDANTS(对 ACCESSIBILITY 不重要且对它的后代而言也不重要) // Check parent mode to ensure we're not hidden. ViewParent parent = mParent; while (parent instanceof View) { if (((View) parent).getImportantForAccessibility() == IMPORTANT_FOR_ACCESSIBILITY_NO_HIDE_DESCENDANTS) { return false; } parent = parent.getParent(); }
    3. 判断 mode 是否为IMPORTANT_FOR_ACCESSIBILITY_YES及是否具有其它和 Accessibility 相关的特性: return mode == IMPORTANT_FOR_ACCESSIBILITY_YES || isActionableForAccessibility() || hasListenersForAccessibility() || getAccessibilityNodeProvider() != null || getAccessibilityLiveRegion() != ACCESSIBILITY_LIVE_REGION_NONE;

    但在android.view.View里面找到一个有点关系的属性:

    /**
     * Shift for the bits in {@link #mPrivateFlags2} related to the
     * "importantForAccessibility" attribute.
     */
    static final int PFLAG2_IMPORTANT_FOR_ACCESSIBILITY_SHIFT = 20;
    

    由于这部分地方涉及到不少位运算,暂时留待后面详细研究。

  • 今天终于把真正查 node 的函数找到了,不过还没完全搞懂查 node 的过程和 compress 在中间造成的不同。先把找的过程贴上来一下:
    提醒一下:前文的connection.findAccessibilityNodeInfoByAccessibilityId中传的 flag 是进行了一个运算后再传给findAccessibilityNodeInfoByAccessibilityIdmFetchFlags | flags,这里其实就是把我们之前预先告诉AccessibilityInteractionClient要添加的AccessibilityServiceInfo.FLAG_INCLUDE_NOT_IMPORTANT_VIEWS信息加入到 flags 中。

    然后 find in path,找到IAccessibilityServiceConnection的实现类android.view.ViewRootImpl

    /**
         * This class is an interface this ViewAncestor provides to the
         * AccessibilityManagerService to the latter can interact with
         * the view hierarchy in this ViewAncestor.
         */
        static final class AccessibilityInteractionConnection
                extends IAccessibilityInteractionConnection.Stub {
            private final WeakReference<ViewRootImpl> mViewRootImpl;
    
            AccessibilityInteractionConnection(ViewRootImpl viewRootImpl) {
                mViewRootImpl = new WeakReference<ViewRootImpl>(viewRootImpl);
            }
    
            @Override
            public void findAccessibilityNodeInfoByAccessibilityId(long accessibilityNodeId,
                    int interactionId, IAccessibilityInteractionConnectionCallback callback, int flags,
                    int interrogatingPid, long interrogatingTid, MagnificationSpec spec) {
                ViewRootImpl viewRootImpl = mViewRootImpl.get();
                if (viewRootImpl != null && viewRootImpl.mView != null) {
                    viewRootImpl.getAccessibilityInteractionController()
                        .findAccessibilityNodeInfoByAccessibilityIdClientThread(accessibilityNodeId,
                                interactionId, callback, flags, interrogatingPid, interrogatingTid,
                                spec);
                } else {
                    // We cannot make the call and notify the caller so it does not wait.
                    try {
                        callback.setFindAccessibilityNodeInfosResult(null, interactionId);
                    } catch (RemoteException re) {
                        /* best effort - ignore */
                    }
                }
            }
    

    这里第一次出现了callback。当 viewRootImpl 为 null 或 viewRootImpl.mView 为 null 时,调用了callback.setFindAccessibilityNodeInfoResult方法,把 null 作为结果返回给callback了。在异步编程里面,callback 的作用相当于同步编程的 return,把处理结果返回给这个函数的调用者。这个函数名称是不是很眼熟?对,它在AccessibilityInteractionClient里出现过,就是咱们一开始建立 connection 并调用其findAccessibilityNodeInfoByAccessibilityId方法那里,同时咱们前面调试时存储mFindAccessibilityNodeInfosResult结果的也是这个类。于是咱们跟踪进去看看
    此时callbackIAccessibilityInteractionConnectionCallback类型的,find in path 发现android.view.accessibility.AccessibilityInteractionClient刚好实现了IAccessibilityInteractionConnectionCallback,其中setsetFindAccessibilityNodeInfosResult方法源码如下:

    /**
         * {@inheritDoc}
         */
        public void setFindAccessibilityNodeInfosResult(List<AccessibilityNodeInfo> infos,
                    int interactionId) {
            synchronized (mInstanceLock) {
                if (interactionId > mInteractionId) {
                    if (infos != null) {
                        // If the call is not an IPC, i.e. it is made from the same process, we need to
                        // instantiate new result list to avoid passing internal instances to clients.
                        final boolean isIpcCall = (Binder.getCallingPid() != Process.myPid());
                        if (!isIpcCall) {
                            mFindAccessibilityNodeInfosResult =
                                new ArrayList<AccessibilityNodeInfo>(infos);
                        } else {
                            mFindAccessibilityNodeInfosResult = infos;
                        }
                    } else {
                        mFindAccessibilityNodeInfosResult = Collections.emptyList();
                    }
                    mInteractionId = interactionId;
                }
                mInstanceLock.notifyAll();
            }
        }
    

    看到了吗?这里把第一个参数 infos 赋给了 mFindAccessibilityNodeInfosResult,也就是说,就是这里把结果存储到mFindAccessibilityNodeInfosResult的。但此时因为 info 是 null,所以其实存的是一个空列表,和我们调试看到的不一样。
    好了,先记下来,callback.setFindAccessibilityNodeInfosResult就是把找到的结果存储到mFindAccessibilityNodeInfosResult的函数,下次见到它记得多留意一下。

    咱们回到android.view.ViewRootImplfindAccessibilityNodeInfoByAccessibilityId方法:

    /**
         * This class is an interface this ViewAncestor provides to the
         * AccessibilityManagerService to the latter can interact with
         * the view hierarchy in this ViewAncestor.
         */
        static final class AccessibilityInteractionConnection
                extends IAccessibilityInteractionConnection.Stub {
            private final WeakReference<ViewRootImpl> mViewRootImpl;
    
            AccessibilityInteractionConnection(ViewRootImpl viewRootImpl) {
                mViewRootImpl = new WeakReference<ViewRootImpl>(viewRootImpl);
            }
    
            @Override
            public void findAccessibilityNodeInfoByAccessibilityId(long accessibilityNodeId,
                    int interactionId, IAccessibilityInteractionConnectionCallback callback, int flags,
                    int interrogatingPid, long interrogatingTid, MagnificationSpec spec) {
                ViewRootImpl viewRootImpl = mViewRootImpl.get();
                if (viewRootImpl != null && viewRootImpl.mView != null) {
                    viewRootImpl.getAccessibilityInteractionController()
                        .findAccessibilityNodeInfoByAccessibilityIdClientThread(accessibilityNodeId,
                                interactionId, callback, flags, interrogatingPid, interrogatingTid,
                                spec);
                } else {
                    // We cannot make the call and notify the caller so it does not wait.
                    try {
                        callback.setFindAccessibilityNodeInfosResult(null, interactionId);
                    } catch (RemoteException re) {
                        /* best effort - ignore */
                    }
                }
            }
    

    前面的分析说明函数没有跑到 else 那里,那咱们直接看一下 if 里面的语句:

    viewRootImpl.getAccessibilityInteractionController()
        .findAccessibilityNodeInfoByAccessibilityIdClientThread(accessibilityNodeId,
                interactionId, callback, flags, interrogatingPid, interrogatingTid,
                spec);
    

    这里的getAccessibilityInteractionController就是获取了一个AccessibilityInteractionController的实例,没有对flags进行任何运算,略过。
    findAccessibilityNodeInfoByAccessibilityIdClientThreadAccessibilityInteractionController的子方法,源码如下:

    public void findAccessibilityNodeInfoByAccessibilityIdClientThread(
                long accessibilityNodeId, int interactionId,
                IAccessibilityInteractionConnectionCallback callback, int flags, int interrogatingPid,
                long interrogatingTid, MagnificationSpec spec) {
            Message message = mHandler.obtainMessage();
            message.what = PrivateHandler.MSG_FIND_ACCESSIBLITY_NODE_INFO_BY_ACCESSIBILITY_ID;
            message.arg1 = flags;
    
            SomeArgs args = SomeArgs.obtain();
            args.argi1 = AccessibilityNodeInfo.getAccessibilityViewId(accessibilityNodeId);
            args.argi2 = AccessibilityNodeInfo.getVirtualDescendantId(accessibilityNodeId);
            args.argi3 = interactionId;
            args.arg1 = callback;
            args.arg2 = spec;
            message.obj = args;
    
            // If the interrogation is performed by the same thread as the main UI
            // thread in this process, set the message as a static reference so
            // after this call completes the same thread but in the interrogating
            // client can handle the message to generate the result.
            if (interrogatingPid == mMyProcessId && interrogatingTid == mMyLooperThreadId) {
                AccessibilityInteractionClient.getInstanceForThread(
                        interrogatingTid).setSameThreadMessage(message);
            } else {
                mHandler.sendMessage(message);
            }
        }
    

    这里做的事情就是把传进来的参数封装到message里面,然后把这个message放到一个队列里面(这里做了一个线程判断,如果是同一线程调用setSameThreadMessage,否则mHandler.sendMessage)。这是 Android IPC(进程间通讯)中的 Messager 通讯方式,这个队列会被 looper 不断查找,如果有内容则逐个交给 handler 处理。因此跟进去sendMessage没有意义(它只是放到队列里面,具体执行不关它的事)。我们留意到这里设了一个作为标识变量:message.what = PrivateHandler.MSG_FIND_ACCESSIBLITY_NODE_INFO_BY_ACCESSIBILITY_ID;

    既然实际上处理的函数是 handler,那么咱们去找 handler。
    AccessibilityInteractionController的构造函数中,我们发现了 mHandler 的初始化语句:

    public AccessibilityInteractionController(ViewRootImpl viewRootImpl) {
            Looper looper =  viewRootImpl.mHandler.getLooper();
            mMyLooperThreadId = looper.getThread().getId();
            mMyProcessId = Process.myPid();
            mHandler = new PrivateHandler(looper);
            mViewRootImpl = viewRootImpl;
            mPrefetcher = new AccessibilityNodePrefetcher();
        }
    

    它是一个PrivateHandler的实例,所以它使用的 handler 应该也是PrivateHandler里的 handler。
    根据 Android IPC 里面 Messager 的介绍,sendMessage后的执行是由 handler 负责的,因此咱们直接去看看PrivateHandler里面的handleMessage方法:

    private class PrivateHandler extends Handler {
            private final static int MSG_PERFORM_ACCESSIBILITY_ACTION = 1;
            private final static int MSG_FIND_ACCESSIBLITY_NODE_INFO_BY_ACCESSIBILITY_ID = 2;
            private final static int MSG_FIND_ACCESSIBLITY_NODE_INFOS_BY_VIEW_ID = 3;
            private final static int MSG_FIND_ACCESSIBLITY_NODE_INFO_BY_TEXT = 4;
            private final static int MSG_FIND_FOCUS = 5;
            private final static int MSG_FOCUS_SEARCH = 6;
    
            public PrivateHandler(Looper looper) {
                super(looper);
            }
    
            ...
    
            @Override
            public void handleMessage(Message message) {
                final int type = message.what;
                switch (type) {
                    case MSG_FIND_ACCESSIBLITY_NODE_INFO_BY_ACCESSIBILITY_ID: {
                        findAccessibilityNodeInfoByAccessibilityIdUiThread(message);
                    } break;
                    case MSG_PERFORM_ACCESSIBILITY_ACTION: {
                        perfromAccessibilityActionUiThread(message);
                    } break;
                    case MSG_FIND_ACCESSIBLITY_NODE_INFOS_BY_VIEW_ID: {
                        findAccessibilityNodeInfosByViewIdUiThread(message);
                    } break;
                    case MSG_FIND_ACCESSIBLITY_NODE_INFO_BY_TEXT: {
                        findAccessibilityNodeInfosByTextUiThread(message);
                    } break;
                    case MSG_FIND_FOCUS: {
                        findFocusUiThread(message);
                    } break;
                    case MSG_FOCUS_SEARCH: {
                        focusSearchUiThread(message);
                    } break;
                    default:
                        throw new IllegalArgumentException("Unknown message type: " + type);
                }
            }
        }
    

    这里由于我们的message.whatPrivateHandler.MSG_FIND_ACCESSIBLITY_NODE_INFO_BY_ACCESSIBILITY_ID,因此执行findAccessibilityNodeInfoByAccessibilityIdUiThread

    private void findAccessibilityNodeInfoByAccessibilityIdUiThread(Message message) {
            final int flags = message.arg1;
    
            SomeArgs args = (SomeArgs) message.obj;
            final int accessibilityViewId = args.argi1;
            final int virtualDescendantId = args.argi2;
            final int interactionId = args.argi3;
            final IAccessibilityInteractionConnectionCallback callback =
                (IAccessibilityInteractionConnectionCallback) args.arg1;
            final MagnificationSpec spec = (MagnificationSpec) args.arg2;
    
            args.recycle();
    
            List<AccessibilityNodeInfo> infos = mTempAccessibilityNodeInfoList;
            infos.clear();
            try {
                if (mViewRootImpl.mView == null || mViewRootImpl.mAttachInfo == null) {
                    return;
                }
                mViewRootImpl.mAttachInfo.mAccessibilityFetchFlags = flags;
                View root = null;
                if (accessibilityViewId == AccessibilityNodeInfo.UNDEFINED) {
                    root = mViewRootImpl.mView;
                } else {
                    root = findViewByAccessibilityId(accessibilityViewId);
                }
                if (root != null && isShown(root)) {
                    mPrefetcher.prefetchAccessibilityNodeInfos(root, virtualDescendantId, flags, infos);
                }
            } finally {
                try {
                    mViewRootImpl.mAttachInfo.mAccessibilityFetchFlags = 0;
                    applyAppScaleAndMagnificationSpecIfNeeded(infos, spec);
                    if (spec != null) {
                        spec.recycle();
                    }
                    callback.setFindAccessibilityNodeInfosResult(infos, interactionId);
                    infos.clear();
                } catch (RemoteException re) {
                    /* ignore - the other side will time out */
                }
            }
        }
    

    这里我们又见到了callback.setFindAccessibilityNodeInfosResult方法,因此可以确定找 node 的具体工作都是这里来完成的,自然过滤也是。
    这里的过程比较复杂,目前还没完全看懂。后面看懂后再把分析贴上来。

  • swift 基础与 oc 基础 at 2015年02月09日

    必须点赞!

  • @mingyuwang 能把正常跑得通的 log 贴上来一下吗?到

    ----|---------------------------------------------------------------------------
        X -[TEST_BUNDLE FAILED_TO_START] (0 ms) (0)
          -[CSSTests testCSSCreate]
    --------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    Test did not run: Simulator 'iPhone 4s' was not prepared: Failed for unknown reason.
    

    这里就可以了。
    估计还是因为 jenkins 建立的 shell 和你能执行成功的 shell 部分配置不一样。

  • @mingyuwangxctool找到一段说明
    In order to your run your tests within a continuous integration environment, you must create Shared Schemes for your application target and ensure that all dependencies (such as CocoaPods) are added explicitly to the Scheme
    这一部分有做了吗?

  • 会不会是由于 jenkins 里面使用的用户不一样?用户不一样会导致各种设置不一样的。我在 windows 下用 jenkins 经常遇到这个问题,本地跑得好好的脚本去到 jenkins 各种报错。但 mac 里面没用过,不是很清楚是不是也是一样的。

  • 已关注。支持!

  • @doctorq 好,不过估计你会比较快。我是边看边查相关资料,看得很慢的。